Kantian and utilitarian theories


One problem for preference utilitarianism concerns how to make interpersonal comparisons though this problem also arises for some other theories of value. This seems certain, maybe even provable, if you throw in the veil of ignorance accessory.

This memory makes her so angry that she voluntarily stabs and kills him with one of the knives. Harrison concludes that since the strongest argument for the claim that animals are conscious fails, we should not believe that they are conscious.

Although Rawls argues for this conception as a conception of justice, others have tried to extend it to cover all of morality. You will see, as we proceed, that we do not do ethics without at least some moral theory.

Such details are discussed in another entry in this encyclopedia see Hooker on rule-consequentialism. Singer attacks the views of those who wish to give the interests of animals less weight than the interests of human beings.

Their professional obligations are deeply informed by their commitments to prevent or reduce harm and to produce a positive balance of goods over Kantian and utilitarian theories harms. Unforeseeably, when she opens my present, the decorative pattern on the knives somehow reminds her of something horrible that her husband did.

However, by doing this we are focusing on the wrong thing, Regan claims. For example, animals that are raised for food in factory farms live lives that are full of unimaginable pain and suffering Singer devotes an entire chapter of his book to documenting these facts.

If being cruel to an animal will make us more likely to be cruel to other human beings, we ought not be cruel to animals; if being grateful to animal will help us in being grateful to human beings then we ought to be grateful to animals.

Kantian ethics

Luckily for them, not for him! The similarities usually cited by proponents of this argument are similarities in behavior, similarities in physical structures, and similarities in relative positions on the evolutionary scale.

Immanuel Kant

That is why human beings should give the interests of other human beings greater weight than they do the interests of animals. Most take moral theories to be prescriptive.


The majority decision in this case asserts that there is no consensus among health care professionals about the precise boundaries of the legitimate practice of medicine, a legal notion similar to the medical-ethics notion of the proper ends of medicine.

Compare one outcome where most people are destitute but a few lucky people have extremely large amounts of goods with another outcome that contains slightly less total goods but where every person has nearly the same amount of goods.

Utilitarians are not a Hedonist. Murderers deserve to be put to death. The flowering of the natural sciences had led to an understanding of how data reaches the brain. Regan argues that in these sorts of cases we must try to minimize the rights that are overriden.

A more popular response is average utilitarianism, which says that the best consequences are those with the highest average utility cf.

Of course, some resist the idea that inflicting suffering in such a case would be gratuitous, which is why this debate continues. I am perfectly happy with this being universalized, because it saves me from having to waste my time helping the needy. For Kant, an act is only permissible if one is willing for the maxim that allows the action to be a universal law by which everyone acts.

Animals and Ethics

A Stakeholder Approach, Boston:Altruism and Volunteerism: The perceptions of altruism in four disciplines and their impact on the study of volunteerism. Ethics is the conscious reflection on our moral beliefs targeting to improve, extend, or refine those beliefs in some way.

Kantian moral and Utilitarianism theories attempt to respond to the ethical nature of human beings. Kantian ethics refers to a deontological ethical theory ascribed to the German philosopher Immanuel ultimedescente.com theory, developed as a result of Enlightenment rationalism, is based on the view that the only intrinsically good thing is a good will; an action can only be good if its maxim – the principle behind it – is duty to the moral.

Theories of Morality (1) Moral Subjectivism Right and wrong is determined by what you -- the subject -- just happens to think (or 'feel') is right or wrong.

When I was an undergraduate, I believed that the prevalence of positivism in the social sciences – the idea of studying social phenomena in an “objective” or “value-free” manner – was one of the great evils in the world.

1. The Concepts of Beneficence and Benevolence. The term beneficence connotes acts of mercy, kindness, and charity. It is suggestive of altruism, love, humanity, and promoting the good of others.

In ordinary language, the notion is broad, but it is understood even more broadly in ethical theory to include effectively all forms of action intended to.

The problem with “critical” studies Download
Kantian and utilitarian theories
Rated 0/5 based on 50 review